Menu of Rubb's Family Supper Club in Wisconsin Dells, Wisconsin, USA

Menu Overview

Rubb’s Family Supper Club, located at 1950 River Rd in Wisconsin Dells, offers a classic supper club experience wrapped in warm hospitality and hearty, well-executed dishes. This family restaurant shines brightest through its commitment to traditional supper club staples like prime rib, New York Strip steak, and an appealingly fresh salad and soup bar that clearly reflects care from scratch.

Walking into Rubb’s feels like stepping into a well-loved local gem. The ambience, complete with white tablecloths and old-school supper club music, sets a relaxed tone that invites diners to linger over their meals and cocktails. Talking about cocktails, the Old Fashioneds and martinis here are remarkable. I especially enjoyed the perfectly crafted Honey Whiskey Old Fashion and the rich Chocolate Martini—each drink balancing bold flavors with smooth, measured spirits.

The menu is diverse but focused, emphasizing quality cuts like the USDA Choice Ribeye and Double Rubbed Prime Rib. The Pan Seared Scallops and Seafood Platter highlight the "Farm and Sea" offerings, delivering fresh, delicate seafood alongside options like roasted duck and bone-in pork chops for those craving bold, meaty flavors. Burgers also show a thoughtful range, from the classic Rubb’s Cheeseburger to the spicy and mushroom Swiss varieties, covering comfort food cravings with finesse.

A true standout is the homemade soup and salad bar. Customers frequently praise the fresh mixings and attentive stocking, with favorites like creamy potato soup bringing a nostalgic depth of flavor that sets a high standard. This attention to foundations helps elevate the entire dining experience, making each bite feel grounded yet refined.

While most reviews highlight a consistently excellent dining experience marked by friendly service and succulent steak preparations, the occasional inconsistency in temperature and doneness reminds diners to set expectations thoughtfully. However, the owner’s visible passion and ongoing efforts to update the establishment suggest a proactive approach to continuous improvement.

In summary, Rubb’s Family Supper Club embodies the heart of Wisconsin supper clubs—a place where top-quality prime cuts, fresh seafood, extensive salad and soup options, and expertly mixed cocktails come together in a cozy, welcoming setting. Whether you’re savoring the Prime Rib Dinner or indulging in their signature Butter Garlic Shrimp alongside a well-balanced margarita, the experience feels like a genuine taste of the region’s hearty culinary tradition. It’s a spot I look forward to returning to, both for the classic dishes and the genuine warmth that underlies every plate served.